The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

Best nail files tried and tested for a salon-worthy manicure

Whether you’re perfecting natural or acrylic nails, these are the tools you need

Pippa Bailey
Wednesday 19 March 2025 14:38 GMT
Even if you don’t want to faff around with cuticles and polish, everyone can appreciate a neat shape and no snags
Even if you don’t want to faff around with cuticles and polish, everyone can appreciate a neat shape and no snags (Tweezerman/Leighton Denny/iStock/The Independent)
Our Top Picks

With the price of a salon manicure rising exponentially, more of us than ever have turned to doing our nails at home. The key to that signature salon finish? A good nail file.

If the cuticle snippers scare you and you’re not great at nail polish application, everyone can appreciate a set of nice smooth, tidy nails. But, for something that’s seemingly such a simple job, there’s actually a lot of variation in the nail file sphere. 

Certainly, there are different materials and different shapes but, rest assured, we’ve done our research on which textures will leave your paws looking pretty and pristine. For instance, metal files can be too harsh and can cause splintering, so we’ve avoided those here; our picks are either traditional emery board (card and sand), crystal (also sold as glass), or sandstone. 

We’ve also covered the filers that cleverly combine buffing (for the top of the nail) with filing and polishing capabilities. And, because emery boards need replacing every three to six months, we’ve even found some brands that offer refills. So scroll on for our top picks and, remember, always file in one direction to prevent splitting.

How we tested

Reviewing them on bare nails, gel nails and sensitive nails (post-gel removal), we paid attention to the durability, effectiveness, eco-friendliness and ease of use of the following nail files. We also considered value for money and, ultimately, looked for the files that afforded us the simplest and most salon-worthy nail maintenance.

Why you can trust IndyBest reviews

Aside from being an established writer, Pippa Bailey has covered all sorts of beauty tools, from foundation brushes to blackhead removers. And, when it comes to nail-specific beauty, she’s quite the expert, having reviewed nude nail polishes, the best pedicure products and more. Below, find her top nail file picks.

1
Tweezerman neon filemates set

Tweezerman copy.jpg
  • Best: Overall
  • Material: Emery
  • Grit: 100/180
  • Why we love it
    • Two types of grit for different degrees of rough/jaggedness
    • Works to work away top layer of gel polish

These are traditional dual-sided emery boards but in two-tone neon, which makes the whole experience more fun. They’re a little thick and cushioned, and have a different grit texture on each side: 100 and 180. Use the finer grit on natural nails and the heavier on acrylics; we’ve also used it to buff the shine off gels before removal. While you could just use one of the three and save the others for when it needs replacing, we like to keep one in our handbag (in the case provided), one on our desk and one by our bed, so you always have one in reach for those pesky snags.

Back to top

2
Margaret Dabbs crystal nail file

Margaret Dabbs.jpg
  • Best: Glass nail file
  • Material: Crystal
  • Grit: Not disclosed, defined as 'extra fine' by the brand
  • Why we love it
    • Gentle on fragile nails
    • Easy to clean
  • Take note
    • Smashable if dropped

If you have brittle nails, or just generally want to treat them a little easier, a crystal or glass nail file is a great option for minimising splitting and weakness and also for getting a nice clean edge. Think of them like a low-impact adaptation of an exercise; they get the job done but with less risk of damage. They can also be washed with soap and water, whereas a traditional emery board can’t really be sanitised, and last far longer. Margaret Dabbs makes luxury products for hands and feet, and its crystal file is nothing short of perfect.

Back to top

3
Natural sandstone nail file

best nail files natural sandstone nail file indybest
  • Best: Natural material
  • Material: Orsa sandstone
  • Grit: Not disclosed, but orsa sandstone varies in grits from 120 – 200
  • Why we love it
    • Eco-friendly
    • Gentle on nails
  • Take note
    • Can leave dust in the base of your toiletry bag

This is a brilliant, planet-friendly option as it’s made from Swedish orsa sandstone, which is natural, very hardwearing, long-lasting (it’s usually used in buildings) and biodegradable. The feel and finish on your nails are more like using a glass or crystal file than emery, as the abrasive grains are very densely packed.

Back to top

4
Leighton Denny quattro four in one nail file and buffer

Leighton Denny.jpg
  • Best: For nails with ridges
  • Material: Emery
  • Grit: 180, 600, 2500, 4000
  • Why we love it
    • Great for fragile nails post gel/BIAB
    • Leaves nails with a polish-like shine
  • Take note
    • A little fiddly to hold

To tackle the texture of the top of the nail bed as well as the shape of the tips, this four-sided file features three different textures as well as an emery board to buff out ridges and add shine. Shape your nails with the file first, then use side “one, remove ridges” (they are labelled) to do just that, followed by “two, smooth nail” to refine further and “three, miracle shine” to buff up a natural shine. We particularly love using this file when we’re giving our nails a break from gels or polish, as it gets nude nails looking their best.

Back to top

5
Tweezerman neon hot four-in-one file

Tweezerman 2.jpg
  • Best: For a salon-worthy finish
  • Material: Emery
  • Grit: 240, 320, 800, 4000
  • Why we love it
    • Easy to get ahold of for precise control
    • Pads are replaceable

For a longer-lasting file, this is a clever option. It features four sides with different textures – file, buff, smooth and shine, as well as four replaceable sheets for each. Once one side has lost its grit from use, simply peel it off and replace it. We also found this short block easier to handle than the longer shape of Leighton Denny’s four-sided one, as you can hold it at both ends at once. 

Back to top

6
Nails Inc easy filer nail file

Nails Inc.jpg
  • Best: For manoeuvrability
  • Material: Stainless steel, glass, ceramic and emery
  • Grit: Not disclosed
  • Why we love it
    • Ergonomic design
    • Leaves nails smooth and shiny
  • Take note
    • Using the internal section is quite fiddly

If you find holding a long thin board uncomfortable, this ergonomic design is a clever alternative. It’s hollow in the middle, so can grip it against your palm as you would a handle. It has three finishes: file, for shaping, smooth, for buffing out ridges, and, inside the loop, shine, to finish with a natural glow. Using the last of the three is a little tricky; we found it best to hold it flat with one hand and move the nails of the other inside it, rather than moving the file itself. 

Back to top

The Verdict: Nail files

Our favourite is Tweezerman’s neon set for its no-fuss, effective finish, bright colours and value for money. If you’re willing to spend a little more for something that will last for years to come, Margaret Dabbs’ crystal file is a very close second.

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in