The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?

8 best blackhead treatments for achieving smoother skin

Discover the hard-working ingredients and formulas that help unclog pores and improve skin texture

Louise Whitbread
Tuesday 01 April 2025 21:21 BST
We’ve put a series of products to the test, spanning cleansers, serums, masks and moisturisers
We’ve put a series of products to the test, spanning cleansers, serums, masks and moisturisers (iStock/The Independent )
Our Top Picks

Blackheads are a common skin concern. The tiny blocked pores sometimes feel like they never really go away, no matter how many times you’ve tried to get rid of them.

According to Dr Hiba Injibar, consultant dermatologist and founder of Dermasurge Clinic, blackheads are “a type of acne caused by clogged pores filled with excess sebum, dead skin cells, and debris. Unlike whiteheads, which are closed, blackheads remain open, and the oxidation of trapped oil gives them their dark appearance. They usually develop in areas with high oil production, such as the nose, chin, and forehead.”

Despite how tempting it can be to squeeze blackheads and watch others doing so – #blackhead has one million views and counting on TikTok – it’s actually one of the most damaging things you can do for your skin. Consultant dermatologist Dr Derrick Phillips told me: “Squeezing blackheads can damage the skin and put you at risk of infection, scarring and hyperpigmentation. You can also push the debris deeper into the pores, making the situation a lot worse.” Instead, he recommends a well-formulated skincare routine.

To tackle blackheads, Dr Injibar advises incorporating ingredients into your skincare routine that help exfoliate and unclog pores. “Salicylic acid is excellent for dissolving excess oil and dead skin, while retinoids help regulate cell turnover and prevent blockages. Niacinamide can reduce oil production and inflammation. You could also use clay masks to help absorb excess oil.” Many of these ingredients can be found across cleansers, masks, serums and moisturisers.

Alongside this, Dr Phillips suggests using a retinoid serum in your evening skincare routine to gently exfoliate and remove oxidised sebum, which will unclog pores and therefore reduce the appearance of blackheads and whiteheads. Taking the advice of the experts on board, I’ve spent weeks testing products that aid the reduction of blackheads to find out which ones are worth your money. Read on for my full review.

How I tested

I tried a variety of products, to see which ones worked best on my oily combination skin
I tried a variety of products, to see which ones worked best on my oily combination skin (Louise Whitbread)

I’ve tested a myriad of products, including cleansers, serums, masks and moisturisers, narrowing it down to the top eight. I examined everything from texture, finish and absorption, as well as ease of application, value for money and, of course, how effective each one was on my oily combination skin.

Why you can trust IndyBest reviews

Louise Whitbread has spent years working in the beauty industry and has tested countless skincare products and solutions, having suffered from acne for many years. From an expert-led feature on minimising acne scarring to her pick of the best skincare for acne-prone skin, Louise knows what to look for when it comes to finding skin solutions that actually work.

The best blackhead treatments for 2025 are:

  • Best overall – Starface star wash + salicylic acid: £12.99, Starfaceworld.co.uk
  • Best budget buy – Simple booster serum 10% niacinamide: £6.33, Amazon.co.uk
  • Best retinal – Medik8 crystal retinal: £49, Medik8.com
  • Best mask – La Roche-Posay effaclar mask: £14.80, Amazon.co.uk

1
Starface star wash + salicylic acid

Starface best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Overall
  • Key ingredients: Salicylic acid, hyaluronic acid and glycerin
  • Size: 150ml
  • Why we love it
    • Nice texture
    • Rinses off easily
    • Doesn’t strip skin

This brand is well loved for its bright yellow star-shaped spot patches and its flavoured lip balms – I’d highly recommend both. Fresh off the production line is the new star wash cleanser and star cream moisturiser (£12.99, Starfaceworld.co.uk), made specifically to tackle breakout-prone and sensitive skin.

Starface black head remover testing shots indybest
This is a simple yet effective way to kickstart a skincare routine (Louise Whitbread)

The cleanser, in particular, won me over with its thick, creamy gel texture that lathers into a lightweight foam before being easily rinsed off. The formula combines salicylic acid, hyaluronic acid and glycerin – three reliable ingredients for reducing breakouts and hydrating the skin. Anyone with oily skin will enjoy this. Despite being relatively affordable, it offers a simple yet effective way to kickstart a skincare routine for treating blackheads and other blemishes.

Back to top

2
Simple booster serum 10% niacinamide

Simple best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Budget buy
  • Key ingredients: Glycerin, niacinamide
  • Size: 30ml
  • Why we love it
    • No irritation
    • Can be used instead of a moisturiser
  • Take note
    • Don’t expect immediate results

Budget beauty brand Simple is a good option if you want to spend less than £10 without compromising on quality skincare. The key ingredient here is dermatologist-recommended niacinamide, which works to reduce inflammation and help balance oil production.

Simple black head remover testing shots indybest
This is a great bookend to any skincare routine and creates a nice smooth canvas for make-up (Louise Whitbread)

It’s a sophisticated formula packed into a milky liquid that feels lovely when applied. If you prefer not to use a moisturiser (especially if you have very oily skin), this is a great bookend to any skincare routine and creates a nice smooth canvas for make-up in the mornings. It feels much more luxurious than its price tag would suggest.

Back to top

3
Medik8 crystal retinal

Medik 8 best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Retinal
  • Key ingredients: Hyaluronic acid, vitamin E, glycerin and retinaldehyde
  • Size: 30ml
  • Why we love it
    • Minimal irritation
    • Fast absorbing texture
  • Take note
    • Make sure to use the correct strength for your skin

With a creamy texture that feels akin to a moisturiser, it’s fast-absorbing and, most importantly, offers minimal irritation. A derivative of vitamin A, retinal acts 11 times faster than standard retinol, as it’s more potent, so you’ll need to consider the strength you’re using. Medik8 offers its crystal retinal product at plenty of strengths, spanning from one to 24 (which equates to a retinal strength of 0.01 per cent to 0.24 per cent). To avoid any issues with sensitivity, if you’re new to using retinal, you should start with a lower strength. Helpfully, the brand has a quiz on its website, so you can find the right option for you.

Medik8 black head remover testing shots indybest
I’ve been using this retinal three times a week as part of my evening routine for years (Louise Whitbread)

I’ve used this three times a week as part of my evening routine for years. I found that, occasionally, there was a tiny bit of dry skin on my nose after using this product, but overall, I found it to be fantastic at tackling hormonal acne, including recurring blackheads. I was also impressed by the brightening and smoothing qualities of this product, which is designed to help lessen pigmentation and increase cell turnover.

  1.  £49 from Medik8.com
Prices may vary
Back to top

4
Skin Rocks the control acid

Skinrocks best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Exfoliating toner
  • Key ingredients: Salicylic acid, niacinamide and panthenol
  • Size: 150ml
  • Why we love it
    • Simple application
    • Made skin smoother and clearer

Beauty blogger turned brand founder and expert Caroline Hirons has long been an advocate for using exfoliating acids via toners as part of a balanced skincare routine, so it’s unsurprising she has developed her own under her brand Skin Rocks. The control acid is a beta-hydroxy acid (BHA), meaning it’s oil-soluble and exfoliates skin to decongest and unclog pores, leaving you with fewer blackheads and a clearer complexion.

Skinrocks black head remover testing shots indybest
This Skin Rocks formula made my skin smoother and reduced blackheads (Louise Whitbread)

To apply, soak a cotton pad in the formula and sweep over a clean and dry face – I concentrated on my nose, chin and forehead, and found, after three weeks, my skin was smoother and clearer with fewer visible blackheads. It's a very easy product to incorporate into your routine, supported by a cleanser and hydrating moisturiser. Despite my skin being prone to rosacea, this exfoliating toner didn’t exacerbate it or lead to any sensitivity issues.

Read more: Best rosacea products for every step of your skincare routine

Back to top

5
Byoma clarifying serum

Byoma best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Serum
  • Key ingredients: Niacinamide, gluconolactone, tri-ceramide complex
  • Size: 30ml
  • Why we love it
    • Fast-absorbing
    • Clear instructions

This serum has a clear gel texture that feels almost as light as water and absorbs in a matter of seconds. The pipette bottle makes for easy application – I preferred to concentrate on blackhead-dense areas, such as my nose and forehead.

Byoma black head remover testing shots indybest
I concentrated application on blackhead-dense areas, such as my nose and forehead (Louise Whitbread)

The cocktail of ingredients includes a tri-ceramide complex, featuring ceramides and fatty acids, alongside lactic acid and zinc, which exfoliate gently, sloughing off dead skin cells and unclogging pores. In just a fortnight of using this formula four times a week, I found my skin felt smoother, and areas of congestion began to clear up.

Back to top

6
Topicals faded brightening and clearing serum

Faded best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: For brightening
  • Key ingredients: Melatonin, tranexamic acid, niacinamide and liquorice root extract
  • Size: 50ml
  • Why we love it
    • Luxurious texture
    • Reduces hyperpigmentation and acne scars
  • Take note
    • May cause irritation if used to frequently

This is a fantastic all-in-one serum that treats myriad concerns, including hyperpigmentation, acne scars, dullness and uneven skin tone.

topicals black head remover testing shots indybest
I also found it to be excellent at reducing post-acne marks (Louise Whitbread)

The rich, creamy serum has a buttery soft texture, but it doesn’t leave skin with a greasy residue. The formula includes azelaic acid, niacinamide and kojic acid, which help to smooth texture, refine the appearance of pores, balance excess oil production and brighten. I also found it to be excellent at reducing post-acne marks, if that’s a concern. Just be sure to exercise caution and only use it once a week to avoid irritation.

Back to top

7
La Roche-Posay effaclar mask

La Roche Posay best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Mask
  • Key ingredients: Cellubeads, panthenol B, argilla and kaolin clay
  • Size: 100ml
  • Why we love it
    • Quickly decongests the skin
    • Feels pampering
    • Rinses off easily

In the short term, clay masks are effective at absorbing excess oil and sebum on the skin. This one from La Roche-Posay utilises argilla and kaolin clay to gently exfoliate and unblock clogged pores. Sitting within the brand’s effaclar range (which is designed for acne-prone skin), the mask has a thick, creamy texture that can easily be smoothed onto targeted areas or across your whole face. Because it's packaged in a tube, there’s very little mess compared with using some products that come in a pot you need to dip your hand into.

La Roche Posay black head remover testing shots indybest
I loved how quickly it gets to work and how easily it rinses off (Louise Whitbread)

Once carefully applied, leave this mask to sit for as little as five minutes or until it has dried, then remove it with warm water and a flannel. I loved how quickly it gets to work and how easily it rinses off, making for a great weekly or monthly treatment that leaves skin looking and feeling less greasy, smoother and refreshed.

Back to top

8
Clinique anti-blemish solutions liquid makeup

Clinique best blackhead treatments review indybest
  • Best: Make-up product
  • Key ingredients: Salicylic acid, lactobacillus ferment and skin-soothing agents
  • Size: 30ml
  • Why we love it
    • Lightweight
    • Neutralises redness
    • Long-lasting

Clinique’s anti-blemish liquid foundation is one of the few complexion products that conceals and prevents breakouts. It’s lightweight, can be blended seamlessly with a few sweeps of your fingers, neutralises redness and keeps shine at bay.

Clinique black head remover testing shots indybest
This foundations has a buildable, matte finish (Louise Whitbread)

The buildable matte finish has salicylic acid as the star ingredient, which is one of the best beta-hydroxy acids for tackling blackheads. I loved the blurring finish and how it left my skin looking clearer without being a heavy full-coverage option.

Back to top

The verdict: Blackhead treatments

Starface’s new star wash + salicylic acid cleanser stole the show thanks to its budget-friendly price tag and luxurious formula packed with blackhead-busting ingredients. If you’re after a retinal, you can’t go wrong with the Medik8 crystal retinal, which is available in many different strengths, offers minimal irritation and can treat blackheads, whiteheads, texture, fine lines and wrinkles all in one.

For more skincare must-haves, check out our expert guide to the best retinol creams

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in