Immortals Fenyx Rising, review: Beneath the irritating jokes, this is a solid alternative to Zelda
Taking its cues from Breath of the Wild, Ubisoft’s latest open-world release is a glib but eventually endearing spin on Greek mythology
Before it’s even booted up, Immortals: Fenyx Rising is fighting an uphill battle. Tarred with a bizarrely unappealing title (pronounced, in case you couldn’t tell, “Phoenix Rising”) and a gameplay premise that seems yoinked wholesale from Nintendo’s 2017 gem The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, Ubisoft’s new open-world adventure game doesn’t exactly scream “franchise starter”.
Adapted (loosely and playfully) from classic Greek mythology, Fenyx Rising sees you control Fenyx, a mortal adventurer charged with saving the Gods from a powerful demon named Typhon. With the aid of weapons, powers, and Icarus’s wings, Fenyx takes on a litany of recognisable monsters – Minotaurs, Gorgons and the like – as well as puzzles, challenges, and the usual miscellaneous open-world busywork. The similarities to Breath of the Wild are many and glaring. Fenyx Rising’s visual sensibilities are a little flatter, a little less polished than its Nintendo-produced forebear, though the creature and character designs have plenty of personality. The combat, terrain traversal and even puzzle-solving also feel ripped from Zelda’s pages. As you progress through the 30-odd-hour story, however, they deepen, feel more like their own thing. There’s also an impressive amount of customisation to be had, vis-à-vis Fenyx’s appearance, weapons and powers.
Where the game really sets itself apart is in its narrative tone, which forswears the sort of dignified earnestness of Zelda in favour of a relentless, almost jarring levity. The whole story is framed with a conversation between Zeus and Prometheus, with the pair’s unreliable bickering sporadically underscoring Fenyx’s actions. The jokes, blunt and frequent, are more irritating than amusing (when walking through a stone-columned temple with Fenyx, for instance, the god Hermes shrugs that “the column motif is a bit played out”), but they do have the welcome effect of deflating the grandeur of the Greek myths, and making them light and malleable.
This year has, incidentally, already seen a first-rate adaptation of the Greek mythos, in the Nintendo Switch roguelike Hades. But while Hades’ darker, slicker and altogether hornier interpretation of the ancient deities remains a cut above the rest, Fenyx Rising has the feel of a bona fide crowdpleaser.
Even for a heavyweight video game publisher like Ubisoft, it’s a daunting prospect trying to capture the essence of what made Breath of the Wild such a universally beloved property. Though it comes off at times like Zelda’s broader, tackier cousin, Fenyx Rising ultimately succeeds because it gets the essentials right: from the dynamic boss battles to the cunningly designed puzzles, via the bracing sense of explorative freedom. Zeus be praised.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies