New York Notebook

Is the American Dream nothing more than an antiquated fantasy?

A trip to the theatre to see hit-musical Hamilton has caused Holly Baxter to ponder whether it really pays to be young, scrappy and hungry for more in the land of opportunity

Tuesday 14 January 2020 20:26 GMT
Comments
Ever one to reminisce, the US like to remember how they struck out on their own against the crown
Ever one to reminisce, the US like to remember how they struck out on their own against the crown (Getty)

In Hamilton – the Lin-Manuel Miranda musical which jammed its toe in the door of history and brought some diversity to the Founding Fathers, the one which Mike Pence was booed at and which gave Barack Obama brief Billboard success with a remix – the eponymous Alexander raps that “just like my country, I’m young, scrappy and hungry”. It’s one of the most well-known phrases from the internationally successful play. You can even get your baby a onesie that has “Young, Scrappy And Hungry” emblazoned on it from the official Hamilton merchandise online store.

Little wonder that that phrase stood out to audiences, especially American audiences: the American Dream is all about being young, scrappy and hungry in a country which owes you nothing but can sell you everything. If you’re scrappy enough and hungry enough, you can get whatever you want: riches, renown, maybe even the presidency. Because this is the land of the free. It’s not an old European throwback with an unelected House of Lords and a parliamentary process that ends with the Queen. It threw tea in the ocean. It struck out on its own. It is the reason why Meghan Markle is helping Harry shake off his shackles while Will and Kate scratch out another year on the wall of their gilded cage.

It all sounds pretty great when you put it that way. But then you remember the pitfalls of being a young country and a lot of it falls down.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in