While the government talks of plans and deterrents, people in small boats die

Editorial: Passing ever more stringent laws and treating refugees ever more harshly hasn’t worked and is unlikely to do so in the future

Wednesday 14 December 2022 21:30 GMT
Comments
(Dave Brown)

The tragic loss of life in the Channel, in the most horrendous circumstances, has promoted an outpouring of concern for those who have died, and for the plight of those rescued in a superlative effort by combined British and French forces.

The capsized vessel, so typical of the type used by desperate refugees seeking shelter in Britain, was also typical of those used so cynically by the people smugglers – flimsy, overcrowded, unseaworthy and, indeed, an accident waiting to happen. All are shocked by the incident, but no one is very surprised. Despite all the calls for action and prime ministerial plans that come and go, it has happened before, and it sadly will happen again.

It is, then, at moments such as these that people are reminded of the human cost of the refugee crisis. These are fellow human beings who have lost their lives, almost drowned or died of hypothermia. They are not, to quote the dehumanising terms that have insinuated themselves into the debate, “illegals”, “invaders” or a “problem”; they have human rights, including the absolute right to seek asylum and the right to life.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in