
The Independent's journalism is supported by our readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn commission. Why trust us?
We evaluated the real-world performance of five VPN services
Trying to choose one of the best VPNs to use alongside your Amazon Fire TV stick can feel a little overwhelming, as there are lots of options available. However, we’re here to help. We've thoroughly tested some of the most popular Fire TV stick VPN apps currently on the market to make your decision a little easier.
VPNs stop others from seeing what you're doing online and where you’re located. These virtual private networks work by masking key information such as your IP address and encrypting your connection, making it appear as though you're practically anywhere else in the world. In essence, a VPN creates a secure tunnel between your device and a remote server.
We've selected five of the most popular Fire TV stick VPN services in 2025 and tested their real-world performance using a UK home wifi connection.
The tests were carried out using an Amazon Fire TV stick 4K max over a high-speed full-fibre home broadband connection (via wifi) on a weekday evening – a reasonable reflection of how the majority of users are likely to use Fire TV sticks.
For a fair speed comparison, we established baseline speeds for both wifi and Ethernet connections, using Speedtest.net, without turning on any of the VPN services. These baseline tests were then followed by testing with each VPN connected, so speed differences for each VPN could then be worked out as a percentage of their respective baseline results. Three main metrics were measured:
All tests were conducted using each app's default settings, as most users want a simple interface. For some extra context, Netflix recommends a minimum of 15 Mbps for 4K content, and 5 Mbps for HD content — a useful benchmark for assessing whether a VPN’s impact on speeds will affect video streaming.
For each service, we also tested connections to both UK and US servers to evaluate both local and long-distance performance. Every Fire TV stick VPN app we tested managed to successfully connect to every streaming service, including Netflix, Disney+, Amazon Prime, BBC iPlayer, ITVX, and more.
Esat Dedazade is a freelance writer, journalist, and content creator with more than 14 years of experience covering tech news and reviews. For The Independent, Esat has conducted considerable research into VPN services, including the ones that are best for Android users as well as for Amazon Fire TV sticks. He's used VPNs to keep his online activity private from intrusive trackers, and also uses the services for work, so he can access county-specific webpages for product information and pricing. The recommendations below are based on his real-world testing, as well as the comparison of each service's features.
Features
Surfshark's app has several important features for streaming security and privacy. Its kill switch is particularly valuable, as it automatically cuts your internet connection if the VPN drops, preventing any accidental exposure of your real location or browsing activity. This is a critical security feature for the Fire TV stick and one that isn’t offered by competing VPN apps.
The CleanWeb feature handily and effectively blocks ads, trackers, and malicious sites, creating a cleaner streaming experience. It’s also potentially faster, eliminating bandwidth-consuming ads and trackers.
It's also worth noting that while Surfshark offers GPS spoofing and Alternative ID features on other platforms, these aren't available on the Fire TV stick version. Having said that, these features are likely to be far less in demand on a device that has a primary focus on content consumption, so this shouldn't be an issue for most users.
Performance
Surfshark delivered impressive performance during our Fire TV stick testing. In our wifi speed tests with a higher baseline of 208Mbps, UK server connections achieved 39Mbps (an 81 per cent decrease), while US server connections delivered 33Mbps (an 84 per cent decrease). Upload speeds showed similar patterns, with UK server connections reaching 33Mbps from a 104Mbps baseline (68 per cent decrease) and US server connections at 37Mbps (64 per cent decrease).
Ping measurements remained stable at 15ms for UK servers (compared to 14ms baseline), though US servers showed a higher latency at 278ms. Despite these percentage decreases, the actual speeds still comfortably exceed the requirements for 4K streaming (15-25 Mbps), ensuring buffer-free viewing experiences.
UI and ease of use
While Surfshark's app isn't as intuitive as some rivals’, it didn’t take us long to get to grips with the layout. The darker interface looks smart on the Fire TV, but the layout is a little illogical.
Features
This Fire TV stick app is notably limited compared to its mobile and desktop counterparts. One of the main features of the Fire TV version is split tunnelling, which enables you to choose which apps route through the VPN and which can use your regular connection.
Many of ProtonVPN's standout features on other platforms – such as Secure Core routing, NetShield ad blocker, preset profiles, Always-on VPN, Alternative Routing, and VPN Accelerator – are not available on the Fire TV stick version. This represents a significant reduction in functionality compared to the company's offerings on other devices.
Despite these limitations, ProtonVPN still benefits from the company's strong privacy reputation. The service operates from Switzerland, a country with strong privacy laws outside of international surveillance alliances, and its apps are open source, allowing anyone to inspect the code for security issues.
Performance
ProtonVPN demonstrated solid technical performance during our Fire TV stick testing, despite the more limited feature set.
Our wifi speed tests, starting from a baseline of 121Mbps, showed that UK server connections achieved 35Mbps (a 71 per cent decrease), while US server connections delivered 32Mbps (a 74 per cent decrease). Upload speeds were relatively well-maintained, with UK server connections reaching 34Mbps from a 105Mbps baseline (68 per cent decrease) and US server connections at 41Mbps (61 per cent decrease).
Ping measurements showed some variation, with UK servers at 60ms (compared to 12ms baseline) and US servers at 222ms. Despite this, the speeds remained more than sufficient for high-definition streaming, easily exceeding Netflix's recommended 5Mbps for HD content.
UI and ease of use
ProtonVPN's Fire TV app strikes a good balance between simplicity and functionality, though it lacks many of the advanced features found in the company’s other apps. However, the server selection screens are organised and simple, so it’s easy to find what you need without endless clicking around.
Features
NordVPN’s Threat Protection feature shields you from malicious websites, blocks intrusive ads and prevents anyone from tracking your streaming. In short, this app enhances your privacy while potentially improving streaming performance by eliminating bandwidth-consuming ads.
The Fire TV app also provides split tunnelling, which enables you to route specific apps through the VPN while keeping others on your regular connection. This is useful for services that might block VPN access. You can also access Meshnet, which enables encrypted connections between your devices for secure file sharing.
A notable limitation of NordVPN's Fire TV app, however, is the absence of a kill switch, which is available in competitor apps from the likes of Surfshark. This means if your VPN connection drops unexpectedly, your real IP address could be exposed until you manually reconnect. For casual streamers, this may not be a major concern, but those particularly focused on privacy should take note.
Performance
NordVPN's app offers several connection protocols, including its proprietary NordLynx technology (based on WireGuard), which is designed for optimal speed and security balance. During testing, we used the recommended 'automatic' protocol setting to reflect the typical user experience.
NordVPN demonstrated better wifi performance than its competitors. With a baseline download speed of 130Mbps, connections to UK servers resulted in speeds of 34Mbps (a 74 per cent decrease), while US server connections achieved 35Mbps (a 73 per cent decrease). These percentage decreases are actually better than most competitors, including Surfshark. Upload speeds fared particularly well, with UK server connections delivering 56Mbps from a 102Mbps baseline (45 per cent decrease) and US server connections reaching 49Mbps (52 per cent decrease).
Ping times remained excellent at 13ms for UK servers (unchanged from baseline), but increased significantly to 164ms for US servers. The speeds remained more than adequate for HD and even 4K streaming, though, which typically requires 15-25Mbps.
UI and ease of use
The NordVPN app feels decidedly feature-packed when you first open it on your Fire TV stick. While this isn't necessarily a bad thing, newcomers might find themselves momentarily overwhelmed by the options. The clear, immediately available list of suggested servers is, however, very useful, letting you jump in instantly, without much scrolling required.
Features
This app uses ExpressVPN’s proprietary Lightway protocol, designed to maintain fast speeds while minimising resource usage on streaming devices. This protocol typically offers better performance than traditional options, making it well-suited for streaming activities.
Just like ProtonVPN and NordVPN, ExpressVPN’s app has split tunnelling, so you can choose which apps route through the VPN and which ones can still use your regular connection. The app also includes an auto-connect capability for quick connections when you launch the app.
It's worth noting some features found in ExpressVPN's mobile and desktop apps, such as the ‘protection summary’ feature and built-in speed test, are not available in the Fire TV stick version.
Performance
ExpressVPN delivers a streamlined Fire TV stick experience that balances security features with ease of use. The app connects swiftly and maintains stable connections, essential qualities for uninterrupted streaming sessions.
Our wifi speed tests found that ExpressVPN is quicker than most of the competition. With a baseline download speed of 134Mbps, UK server connections delivered 43Mbps (a 68 per cent decrease), while US server connections achieved 37Mbps (a 72 per cent decrease). Upload speeds were particularly impressive, with UK server connections reaching 73Mbps from a 103Mbps baseline (29 per cent decrease) and US server connections delivering 64Mbps (38 per cent decrease).
Ping response times remained low at 15ms for UK servers (unchanged from baseline), while US servers showed a predictable increase, to 161ms. These speeds still comfortably exceed the requirements for 4K streaming on services such as Netflix.
UI and ease of use
ExpressVPN has clearly put significant thought into making its Fire TV app as painless as possible to use. The interface is refreshingly clean and uncluttered, with a prominent connection button and intuitive navigation. The simplified design is less intimidating than those of its rivals, such as NordVPN, making it ideal for VPN novices. The app strikes a good balance between functionality and ease of use, though it doesn't offer as many advanced features as some competitors.
Features
The CyberGhost VPN offers a straightforward VPN user experience, with a clean interface featuring a prominent connection button and simple server selection. The app includes several useful features, including ad/tracker blocking to improve streaming performance, and split tunnelling capabilities that let you route specific apps through the VPN, while keeping others on your regular connection.
Connection customisations include the choice between WireGuard and OpenVPN protocols, enabling you to prioritise either speed or security, depending on your needs. However, the Fire TV app lacks the dedicated streaming servers available in CyberGhost's desktop apps.
Performance
Our tests of the CyberGhost VPN app found mixed results. In our wifi speed tests, from a baseline of 161 Mbps, UK server connections delivered 39 Mbps (a 76 per cent decrease), while US server connections achieved 24 Mbps (an 85 per cent decrease). Upload speeds remained relatively stable, with UK server connections reaching 39Mbps from a 104Mbps baseline (63 per cent decrease) and US server connections at 42Mbps (60 per cent decrease).
Ping measurements were competitive at 23ms for UK servers (compared with 13ms baseline), and quite good for US servers at 150ms – notably better than some competitors. While these speeds show significant percentage decreases, the absolute values remain sufficient for streaming needs, with even the US server speeds comfortably exceeding Netflix's HD streaming requirements.
UI and ease of use
If you're new to VPNs, CyberGhost's Fire TV app might be just what you're looking for. The interface takes a pared-back less is more approach, with a connection button dominating the screen – you can’t miss it. The design philosophy focuses on simplicity, making it extremely accessible for beginners. What CyberGhost lacks in advanced features, it makes up for in straightforward usability, making it an excellent choice for those new to VPNs or who simply want basic protection without complexity.
After thorough testing, Surfshark is our top recommendation for Amazon Fire TV sticks. Its combination of essential security features (including a kill switch), strong performance, and unlimited device support put it a touch beyond its competitors.
NordVPN offers excellent features, such as threat protection, and demonstrated superior streaming performance with better speed retention than several competitors. However, the absence of a kill switch on its Fire TV app is a privacy issue. However, this is a fair technical issue. for casual streamers focused primarily on performance, NordVPN remains an excellent choice.
ExpressVPN delivers a polished user experience with its Lightway protocol and split tunnelling capabilities, but it lacks some of the features found in its mobile and desktop apps. CyberGhost provides a beginner-friendly experience with useful features such as ad blocking, split tunnelling, and protocol selection, making it ideal for VPN newcomers, despite showing significant speed reductions on distant servers.
For most Fire TV stick users, Surfshark represents the best overall choice, combining essential security features, unlimited device connections, and reliable streaming performance. Those prioritising streaming performance may prefer NordVPN, while those seeking the most user-friendly experience should consider ExpressVPN or CyberGhost.
Want more recommendations? Check out our TV buying guides